Home » The Watercooler for 07/04/08 9:00 AM
The Watercooler for 07/04/08 9:00 AM
DFA's home for a free form, open-ended discussion of what matters most to committed progressive activists.
Watercooler resets everyday at 1am, 9am and 5pm. Past threads can be found in the Watercooler Archive
Show: Expand All Reply
It would appear that Obama has shifted from his early and admirable attack mode to the John Kerry style of being on defence (FISA, Iraq withdrawal, faith-based nonsense, etc.)
This does not bode well...............
- Hillary's base was further to the right than we thought.
By Phil Specht on Jul 4, 2008 7:47 AM EDTObama must do the necessary work of bringing most of them on board, hence the shift, but it is indeed painful to watch how far to the right he thinks he needs to go.
John doesn't understand this. He equates the doomed campaign of John Kerry, a perfectly acceptable presidential aspirant but so dreadful a candidate you could observe the campaign's failure from a mile away, with Obama's. There are nothing more than cosmetic similarities, but it's boring to have to keep repeating it for the benefit of someone who's not listening.
Pay attention Tom. Obama is heading down the Kerry path. Kerry's early July numbers vs Bush were as good or better than Obama's. And Kerry wasn't advocating goofy things like throwing Federal dollars at faith-based charities
Where's all the posters who were polled that wanted to blog to stay on topic?
HJ...I'm hoping that Obama doesn't loose his base with his shift to the center...I'm also hoping he'll take a sharp left turn once in the WH, either by choice or by force of all those getting engaged in the process. Of those that I talk to, most are more fed up with what has happened to America in the last seven years than are excited about BO. I think he's making a big mistake but what do I know...I'm just a regular working guy who talks to lots of other regular working people.
Off to enjoy the festivities today...happy 4th everyone.
- We are in the heat of battle over FISA, today is the day many of us march in parades with our Representatives and Senators.
By Phil Specht on Jul 4, 2008 8:13 AM EDTwaiting for the parade to start is always one of the best times to have a conversation with them.
It is unbelievable to me that Charles took a post about that fight from Jim Dean featuring Russ Feingold off the front page and put it in a trash bin that kicks you clear out if you post. Trashing his own current mission right now. This is the only political fight on the front burner. DFA has taken a stand, and Charles trashes it. unbelievable
How he keeps his job after Jim finds out will be a mystery.
Since i hardly ever drink water, if I can help it, the water-cooler idea leaves me unimpressed. Also, I think it's rude to talk while eating or drinking and to walk around with either in one's hand. The American obsession with drinking water has always been perceived as peculiar by people who are used to boiling their water for health.
The water fountains in the schools were always a nuissance, even when they weren't objectivications of segregation. That they have now been largely removed because the pipes were lead and contaminated the water is not surprising. That DFA staff want to replace them with water coolers is so nineteen fifties.
It's my sense that DFA have no concept of how people use BFA for their home page, for example, and how annoying it is to have to go searching for where the action is. Most entities with a presence on the web would give their eye teeth for a large number of people using their site as their home page. That lots of DFAers do it, is evidenced by the fact that lots of people pop in and leave a comment when they do a check and find something particularly interesting and then we never hear from them for months.
I have one son who lives in Florida and reads Hannah regularly. I don't permit comments there. Three or four times a year he'll call with some observation or other he wants to share and sometimes he emails a link to another web site he thinks i should see. We are definitely on the same wave length and don't need to be in contact on a daily or weekly basis to maintain that connection. Ditto for BFA.
Danny and Charles seem to be the kind of folk who need to call home on a regular schedule. It's my sense that's only necessary for people who don't have much in common with the people they call. Feel free to disagree--anyone............
Since I don't have a left mouse or pad, it's really cumbersome to post, so I won't be doing much. Daughter suggests perhaps the keypad needs to be vacuumed. I'm a little reluctant lest some dirt get stuck in an even more debilitating spot.
Now we don't have to contend with those pesky blog posters who insisted on exposing us to their annoying on topic sentiments.
I disagree and I wonder why the personal attacks.
Well, you'd certainly be abdicating your responsiblity as hall monitor for the unsubscribed if you agreed, wouldn't you?
The personal attacks, as you describe them, are actually a joke. Before the new blog protocol was implemented, we used to joke around. To avoid such levity, you can train your attention on the main, sanctioned blog post threads.
A joke?
Danny and Charles seem to be the kind of folk who need to call home on a regular schedule. It's my sense that's only necessary for people who don't have much in common with the people they call. Feel free to disagree--anyone............
That doesn't sound like a joke to me. Maybe I am wrong. I just don't get why Danny and I are getting bashed with personal attacks. No one has attacked any of you, yet all day yesterday and last night and I assume later today.... many people at the Watercooler take personal shots at Danny and I. I just think it is odd.
Why is it Tom that you don't think that is odd? Should people be attacking me personally? Saying things like Charles has to call home to his momma. I mean the attack doesn't even make sense.
I was referring to my own comment, to which you replied. I don't agree with those sort of attacks towards you and Danny at all, although they don't seem serious enough to take to heart. And I don't think I've indulged in any of those types of attacks, unless you think I attacked you by calling you a hall monitor for the unsubscribed.
If you want my honest advice, I think you've developed a program that its users don't care for, so you're being exposed to this type of malevolence, if that's what you view it. Personally, I'm detecting more frustration than anything, and the ones who are experiencing it see these types of complaints as their only means of protest or avenue for advocating a policy reversal. They certainly don't feel that HQ has been responsive to many of their suggestions.
If these changes are going to be implemented in autocratic fashion, I would definitely expect more such attacks. You might as well reconcile yourself to it. If I were you, I'd be more concerned about the posts of people like Jo who have told us they're leaving.
Seriously Charles, you and Danny are the public faces of what to US look like gestapo techniques -- we see you as storm troopers, authoritarian personalities who have given us absolutely no reason other than "many complaints" (btw you've provided zero evidence) that we don't stay on topic.
If you and Danny (or whoever is really pulling the strings in Burlington on this issue) would give us a reasonable explanation and a vision of where you are going with DFA in general and BFA in particular, we would be happy to listen to some reasonable sales pitches.
Btw Charles, don't know if you've noticed but none of your Freshman Journalism students who are writing the only threads being front paged ARE NOT COMMENTING AT ALL at the sanctioned threads.
If I were you I would expect more tomatoes (but safe ones lol) thrown your way, not less. WE ARE ANGRY HERE.
You don't want to have a smaller number of supporters than your opponent. Nobody really remarks on the Democratic presence unless it is meager, or really large so pump it up.I urge you to spend the next couple of days walking in one, don't just watch. (and if you are running remember next year right after Halloween is the best time to buy the candy to throw to the kids lol). kids like those stickers too and you get the pleasure of seeing them the rest of the celebration anywhere you look and there is always room for a person or two on either side of the candidate helping with the stickering
my son and I are doing three and we get the added bonus of seeing the Obama Llama in action
happy holiday patriots
just wanted to mention again, in case you missed it, that the coverage of Obama's faith speech was quite extensive in the small (16 pages) local paper we found in the middle of nowhere in Antonito, Colorado. The way I see it is that to the extent human behavior has to be modified to be socially acceptable and supportive, the establishments of religion have a useful role to play. It just shouldn't be combined with the physically coercive powers we delegate to the agents of government. That's why they need to be kept separate, but not necessarily excluded. (there is a difference between separation and segregation, despite the fact that the Supreme Court has determined that to keep people appart by force makes them fundamentally unequal--a truth that applies to recent immigrants who aren't citizens, as well. It's the ability to use force which puts the agents of government under restrictions which ordinary people and eleemosynary institutions don't labor under. The agents of government are precluded from using religious institutions as enforcers and vise versa.
The problem with what the Bushes arose from the fact that it was their intent to make establishments of religion part of the coercive regimen. Since the suborning of the private for-profit corporations wasn't achieving all the subjugation of the population that was wanted, they hit on the non-profit sector to do their dirty work. This agenda has now become apparent to the non-profits and faith-based sector and that's why they are retreating in droves. They have come to realize that what was expected was that they sell their birth-right (their independence) for a mess of porridge.
To be on message for a moment--it probably strikes some Iraqis as ironic that the bombs bursting in air give proof that their country is still there, as well. If the U.S. had won, the bombs would have fallen silent a long time ago.
To be on message for a moment--it probably strikes some Iraqis as ironic that the bombs bursting in air give proof that their country is still there, as well. If the U.S. had won, the bombs would have fallen silent a long time ago.
This is a brilliant paragraph imo.
eleemosynary - I always have to look up this word and the one that means nuevo riche :~)
As I've opined before, the issue in FISA is bigger than the interdiction of domestic communications. It's whether the whole strategy of waging war in cyberspace (targeting an "enemy's" communications networks for destruction) is valid. We saw overt evidence of this strategy in the destruction of Iraq's "command and control structures" evidenced by the destruction of power generating stations and transmission lines, as well as the destruction of electronic facilities in Bosnia. These were examples of the use of blunt or bruit force. "Taking out" transmission nodes and satellite installations is a more surgically precise exercise, but the terraine has to be mapped. That's what the suborning of the telecom facilities was supposed to accomplish.
There is a long tradition of enemies destroying the libraries of their opponents. The accumulations of human wisdom and knowledge haven't been "lost" in history. They were destroyed by vandals who wanted to return their opponents to the "stone age" and make them easier to control.
One could even argue that the destruction of the public system of education has been motivated by a desire to subjugate the population--the equivalent of "barefoot and pregnant" for a whole population whose only use is to be controlled.
- The Declaration of Indiependence read on NPR
By Pat in Colorado on Jul 4, 2008 9:00 AM EDTMorning Folks,
Looks like the blog is open this morning. Some sunshine after the authoritarian declarations of Charles last night. Reminded me of Charles on MASH.
Listened to the Declaration of Independence on NPR and was struck by how our George has violated so many of the principles stated, not only here, but also in Iraq and around the world.
I thought of the words of dedicating life, honor, and fortunes for the good of the Republic, and it made me sadder than ever how far we've fallen, how Eisenhower warned of the collusion between the military and industry, and we are seeing it.
It seemed to me that we should be rising up in revolution, but muskets and camouflage are not the ways to do it. The blog allowed for free speech, and we gathered and spoke freely. It has been a flame of light and fire, and I have learned from you all and re-examined some of my own ideas and beliefs. There's also been a kind of extrasensory perception, or whatever we might call it, a stimulation and response to ideas and perceptions that at times seemed extraordinary, a synchronicity that reflected a consciousness more than just literal.
Now, and it hasn't been made clear in any way, the blog is going to change. The postings will be censored, relegated to a side category, and then deleted after three hours. Is this being done for money? Is this being done for the purpose of eventually getting rid of the blog altogether? The statement that a majority voted for this is patently false. When Howard Dean asked us to vote on whether or not he should take public funding, there was an actual vote. There has been no vote.
But, we go on. Our lives have been wonderful by comparison to former generations and to many peoples around the world. We've had so much in the way of living, opportunities, resources, safety, health, and almost anything humans can hope for. How do we then continute to contribute in the ways we can in our society?
Happy Fourth Folks.
I'm going camping today. What are you all doing?
Not composing posts destined for this septic tank!
Huron John -
If you call it a septic tank and spend all your time complaining about it - it will be a septic tank.
If instead, you continued your postings just like you used to, you and everyone else here could have the same kind of great discussions that happened here at Blog for America before.
You have the power to make that choice.
or is it a plop in...
I'm going to exercise my right to free speech in public Charles...I hope the organizers
of the festivities don't make me go to the back street.
How's about we poll those who actually post here... Is the Watercooler a good idea?
1 nay!
Thinking of composing a KOS diary on the assassination of the DFA blog.
Those of us who were Deaniacs remember that a theme of the campaign was that we were responsible for building and maintaining "The Great American Conversation." It all tied together: "In your hands, not mine, lies the future of this nation," the Doc would tell us, and we'd believe it, and go forward. We generated posters, bumper stickers, software, campaign tools. in a way that had never been done before.
In those days, the blog was the center of a lot of these activities. You know what the first "DFA training" was? It was when I suggested Meetup groups kick in $20 each and send representatives to the 21st Century Democrats training in DC, and that those representatives bring the information back to their groups and pass them on. We had jc's and demetrius' and others art - better than what the "pros" were putting out, all shared here, generated from ideas begin here, and refined through conversation.
Now we are told "The Great American Conversation" is to be shunted off the "the watercooler." We need to be more serious and issue oriented. Our comments need to relate to the main post. This is a mistake as well as being a betrayal of the history and heritage of this blog.
Synergy happens when seemingly unrelated actions interact in unexpected ways. This can only happen when there is a critical mass of activities and those activities are unfocused. This is the power of what has become a buzzword, but is still valid, "outside the box" thinking. Follow down the normal trail and there is no solution. Step off the trail, and there's no telling what you will find. Bread mold may become penacillin.
BFA will not become stronger by being more like Kos. BFA will become stronger by promoting what it is. BFA will become stronger when DFA HQ uses it like Dean for America did -- as a window into DFA operations, a place to discuss future activities, plan and synergize, and build community. There have been folks who have left, but not because of the conversational tone. Generally, it's been because of specific posters and postings. That can be controlled now with the rating system. Go out and actively invite perople back. Open the shutters between HQ and the blog again and make this the organizational and creative tool it was during the campaign.
We don't need another Kos. We have one already.
Good post Rich. I agree with most of what you wrote, except for your positive view of the rating system.
To me, that system simply provides an anonymous avenue for inarticulate cowards to attack people they don't like, rather than go to the trouble of composing and posting an opposing view
Charles on MASH. Who do you think you are? Most of us have paid to join DFA, have contributed, have been involved for yesrs. Yet, you and others have made a decision to kill the blog, and then you have the nerve to preach that it will be the same if we just do what we are t old.
Where do you get off? You also lied and said the majority wanted this. There are over 65,000 mebmers according to the website. You polled 65,000 members? Right. I don't recall being given a vote, nor my husband, nor anyone who has posted lately.
So, has the website been sold? Is that it, and the new corporate managers want to make it into a Daily KOS? What's going on? Neither you, nor Danny, nor Jim Dean, nor anyone has been forthright.
Well, okay, but you've betrayed the very principles that Howard Dean stood for, power from the grassroots, the people as participants.
Shame on you. I'm shaking my teacherly finger at you, you pompous ass. By the way, I really hate name calling, but there is a time for it.
Does that feel better? Now that you have called me names?
Not every decision is made based on polling. Based on the number of complaints about the old commenting format that we have received through out the years... a number that far out strips the number of people currently complaining about this change now... and the feedback we have received from DFA leaders and progressive guest bloggers when we have asked them why they stopped posting blogs on BFA and what it would take to get them back... we felt we had two options. One was to just delete all off topic comments. The other was to create a space where the freeform conversations could continue. Thus the Watercooler was created.
There is no shame is trying to meet the needs of the entire DFA community, I will continue to do my best at respecting everyone's views, including yours... even when you attack me personally and call me a lair.
- my anger has contributed to the typos. Sorry.
By Pat in Colorado on Jul 4, 2008 10:26 AM EDT- Items learned from Washington Journal this morning...
By Annilow on Jul 4, 2008 10:36 AM EDTMordechai Vanunu is an Israeli who was responsible for our first knowledge that the Israelis had nukes. For 'outing' Israel, he was lured by a modern Mata Hari out of Britain to another place where he could be arrested and prosecuted. He spent many years in prison and in solitary confinement. Today he seeks asylum out of Israel, but he can't get out and the Israelis oppress him (Annilow's 'cliff notes' on the Wiki article which I will now link):
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mordechai_Vanunu
Note to self: quit using parens - you never remember to close them.
Also from CSPAN this morning:
An author and scholer named Felzenberg who has written a book on the Presidents and how they rate, based on 6 criteria he has based loosely on how he grades students. The 6 are: character, vision, competence, foreign policy, economic policy, human rights, and legacy (from B&N website which I will link in a moment). He rates people about how you would expect - Lincoln first, Washington a close second and the Roosevelts in the top tier. He puts Kennedy at the top of the second tier. He puts Clinton at about the middle of the middle. He kind of danced around Bush -- I think he thinks it's too soon to say. His most interesting comments were about Herbert Hoover. He said Hoover was the Bill Gates of his day. That contrary to popular opinion that Jimmy Carter is the greatest ex-president, that in fact Hoover was -- that he was a great philanthropist.
AND ONE MORE THING
An advantage to the Back of the Bus is you don't have to be paranoid about new threads -- just keep an eye on the time :~)
...just as you've provided no evidence of 'many complaints' about the blog, you've provided no evidence of how you chose the people who got scholarships to Netroots Nation. Howard would be proud no?
Charles said if we keep thinking the water cooler is a septic tank, it will become one. Here's an idea, let's keep thinking the staff is competent, communicative, and cooperative and they will become so. They have the power to make that happen.
Excellent post Pat and Rich.
Another comment on the mechanics.
Why do I keep getting shunted back to the homepage after each post on this verdamte water cooler?
I would definitely like to see a blog post asking BFA members whether they approve of the "Water-cooler" concept.
I predict you'll be inundated with negative responses.
And just look at the current thread. It's like watching grass grow, but not as exciting.
- They did just the opposite of what they should do
By Fred from Oregon on Jul 4, 2008 11:32 AM EDTThey should put the troll posts out to pasture, not the steady bloggers. Now the trolls can stay on the main page as long as their post is germaine to the main theme. what a pisser. Oh well, got to play the hand you're dealt, I guess.
We'll make the water cooler the main blog. It's a dictatorship. Just put the message out to newcomers once in a while to let them know. HQ will get their act together sooner or later.
And who knows, once in a while there may be a main theme worth posting about.
- Is it me? Or do we have to go back to the water cooler in two steps?
By Fred from Oregon on Jul 4, 2008 11:16 AM EDTevery time we post? It doesn't seem to reload the water cooler when I post? I have to do another click on the pull down menu to see the post
It's not you -- and I think I'll switch to rice from potatoes or grow my own - thx Fred.
It's a bug and our tech department will fix it as soon as they can on Monday.
I linked to this on the main blog post. Eugene Robinson's piece *A Special Brand of Patriotism*
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/07/03/AR2008070302450.html
Hope everyone has a happy and safe 4th of July. We have friends visiting so we'll be busy. Going for a hike so we can eat a lot later. LOL
is that the water cooler seems to finish loading a little faster than the main blog page, and so far, I have always gotten my enhancements.
- Here's a hot potato (no pun intended :~)
By Fred from Oregon on Jul 4, 2008 11:46 AM EDTOur strict, chemical-laden diet
<!--subtitle--><!--byline-->
On my way to a golf tournament in Sun Valley, Idaho, I passed mile after mile of potato fields and thought about a book, "The Botany of Desire" by Michael Pollan.
One of the chapters is about the potato industry and the 14 applications of pesticide that go into those spuds. After one particularly virulent poison is applied to fight pests, no human being can be allowed to walk onto the field for five days — even for an emergency repair on those huge rolling irrigation systems. Potato farmers, some of whom are farming more than 3,000 acres of potatoes, will only eat those they grow naturally in their own vegetable gardens....
Add your comment
(to reply directly to a comment, click the reply icon for that comment)You must be logged in to post comments
If you already have an account, login below, otherwise signup now
| My DFA | |
| Members | |
| Groups | |
| Events | |
| Candidates | |
![]() |
|
Blog for America
-
Millions Watch Obama's Speech
By DFA Staff on Aug 29, 2008 9:00 PM EDT -
It's Time For Obama
By Edward Fletcher on Aug 29, 2008 5:04 PM EDT -
Palin on the VP
By DFA Staff on Aug 29, 2008 3:00 PM EDT -
McCain chooses Palin
By DFA Staff on Aug 29, 2008 12:00 PM EDT -
66
By DFA Staff on Aug 29, 2008 9:00 AM EDT
Recommended Blog Posts
-
A conversation with a ghost.
By Ed Tubbs on Aug 28, 2008 4:26 PM EDT -
Democratic Women Center Stage at the DNCC
By Susan Rowe on Aug 28, 2008 12:19 PM EDT -
6th Annual DemocracyFest ~ 2009!
By Jessica Falker on Aug 22, 2008 10:11 AM EDT -
McCain's Mansions: The Real Elitist
By Susan Rowe on Aug 21, 2008 4:20 PM EDT -
DC4D is an old friend of Judy Feder
By Keshini Ladduwahetty on Aug 21, 2008 1:11 PM EDT
Recent Blog Posts
-
Palin and the Environment
By Edward Fletcher on Aug 29, 2008 9:19 PM EDT -
Did anyone notice the purple tie?
By Edward Fletcher on Aug 29, 2008 9:10 PM EDT -
Millions Watch Obama's Speech
By DFA Staff on Aug 29, 2008 9:00 PM EDT -
Obama Telecommunications Policy
By Imn2Paine on Aug 29, 2008 8:51 PM EDT -
Barack Did His Part, Now Let's Do Ours
By Kate Drazner on Aug 29, 2008 8:12 PM EDT





- Off Topic
By Huron John on Jul 4, 2008 6:53 AM EDTJust checked out the trashcan--nothing yet. Maybe this post will kick things off.
Obama has posted a spirited, condescending, unapologetic defense of his FISA position:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/barack-obama/my-position-on-fisa_b_110789.html
To me, it is utterly unpersuasive, does not address the issue that the existing FISA legislation is more than adequate, continues to parrot Repug talking points, and offers the lame fig leaf that he will "work to remove immunity"
I predict it will be completely ineffective in stemming the tidal wave, the blizzard, the avalanche of criticism and cutoffs of donations by supporters who are not into blind acceptance of stupid decisions.